The post-crucifixion history of the separation between followers of Jesus (early Christians) and non-following Jews was a gradual process, not a single event. Modern scholars describe it as the “parting of the ways,” spanning from the 1st to the 4th century CE, with Christianity emerging as a distinct, predominantly Gentile religion while Judaism evolved into Rabbinic Judaism.
Early Period (30–70 CE): Christianity as a Jewish Sect
After Jesus’ crucifixion (c. 30 CE), his followers—mostly Jews—remained within Judaism. They attended synagogues, observed the Torah, and viewed Jesus as the Messiah fulfilling Jewish scriptures. The movement spread among Jews in Jerusalem and the Diaspora.
Paul’s missions (40s–60s CE) brought tensions: he argued Gentiles could join without full Torah observance (e.g., circumcision), decided at the Council of Jerusalem (c. 50 CE, Acts 15). This allowed growth among Gentiles but created internal debates. Most early Christians still identified as Jews.
Destruction of the Second Temple (70 CE)
The Roman destruction of the Temple ended sacrificial worship, forcing adaptation for all Jews. Temple-based sects (e.g., Sadducees) declined, while Pharisaic/Rabbinic Judaism emphasized Torah study, prayer, and synagogues.
For Christians, this reinforced beliefs that Jesus’ death superseded Temple sacrifices (e.g., Hebrews). It accelerated Gentile dominance, as Christianity no longer needed Jerusalem’s Temple. Jewish Christians faced harder integration into post-Temple Judaism, widening the social divide.
Late 1st–Early 2nd Century: Growing Distinctions
By the late 1st century, the “Birkat HaMinim” (a synagogue prayer against “heretics”) may have targeted Jewish Christians, making synagogue participation difficult (evidenced in John 9:22). The “Council of Jamnia/Yavneh” (c. 90 CE) discussions standardized Jewish practices but did not formally exclude Christians or fix the canon against them.
New Testament texts (e.g., Matthew, John) show increasing polemics against “the Jews.” Christianity became more Gentile, with leaders lacking Jewish ties. Works like Justin Martyr’s Dialogue with Trypho (c. 160 CE) argued Christians were the “true Israel,” inheriting God’s covenants, while Judaism was obsolete.
Bar Kokhba Revolt (132–135 CE): A Decisive Moment
Simon Bar Kokhba’s revolt against Rome claimed messianic status (supported by Rabbi Akiva). Many scholars see this as pivotal: Jewish Christians refused to join, viewing Jesus as the true Messiah. Reports (e.g., Eusebius, Justin) claim Bar Kokhba persecuted Christians.
The revolt’s failure devastated Judea: massive deaths, enslavement, and bans on Jewish practices. Hadrian renamed Jerusalem Aelia Capitolina (pagan city) and Judea Syria Palaestina. Jewish life shifted to Galilee; Jewish Christians largely disappeared or marginalized. This revolt solidified the split, as surviving Judaism became Rabbinic and non-messianic, while Christianity distanced itself further.
Later Developments (2nd–4th Centuries)
By the mid-2nd century, Christianity was mostly Gentile-led, with distinct practices (e.g., Sunday worship). Constantine’s conversion (312 CE) and Christianity’s state status (4th century) finalized separation: Christians saw themselves as a new covenant people, often with anti-Jewish rhetoric.
The separation stemmed from theological differences (Jesus’ messiahship, Torah observance for Gentiles), social factors (Gentile influx, synagogue exclusions), and historical traumas (70 CE and 132–135 CE destructions). It was mutual and uneven across regions, but by the 2nd century, the paths had diverged irreversibly.
Leave a Reply